This was pizza heaven for me. Extra cheesy and pure chaos. One bite forced me to shovel each slice down the hatch. The garlic knot ls and the garlic bread were killer too! Definitely coming back

We got a cheese, pepperoni and a ceaser salad. Asked for the pizza to be well done which it was nice and crispy. Ordered for take out. Both pizzas where good. Ceaser salad dressing was to fishy for us. Salad itself was fresh and crisp.

Good pizza I only gotten the pepperoni better never been in the store or service but the pizza is pretty greasy but that doesn't make it bad it makes it better if anything

Amazing pizza and friendly service always, always a treat when I bring Buccaneer pizza to a party and everyone loves it. I love coming here for a slice of pizza and cold beer, however recently went through a prison themed gut job renovation so every time I ate pizza here it feels like I just did time. What's UP with that??

Buccaneer is the place to stop if you are bringing take out food for a large party. We order their fettuccine with chicken 1/2 tray and Caesar salad family size for a group of 8 and it is the perfect meal for the value, not to forget to mention it is very tasty.

Ordered a half pepperoni jalapeño and half sausage mushroom pie, along with chicken Alfredo pasta with garlic bread. I was pleasantly surprised! Very solid pizza and pasta! Ingredients taste pretty fresh and the dough is pretty soft and has a hint of sweetness, while the tomato sauce has a little kick. Each bite felt heavy (Not a bad thing) was full of cheese, toppings, sauce, and dough. Definitely better than any other corporate pizza chain (Pizza Hut, Dominos, etc.)

Second time trying Buccaneer Pizza. The first time was better. We got a large cheese pizza and it was delicious. Second time we ordered a cheese pizza and it was not good. It was burnt and over cooked. There was black on the crust. And under the pizza was black. I could even eat it. The crust and dough was burnt. Disappointed. My salad was fresh. It had a lot of fresh fruit on top. But the dressing didn't really complement the salad fixings. The salad was a miss for me. Overall, seems like hit or miss. We had a really good experience the first time we ordered from here. And second time was not good. Bad experience second time around.

Buccaneer is a bit on the pricey side for pizza but you are paying up for good quality (and quantity of) ingredients and a consistently delicious pizza. Recently (April 2024) ordered a medium Hawaiian pizza (pineapple and Canadian bacon; $24) and I can't lie, every bite was good including the crust. Perfectly chewy bread that wasn't too doughy, nice layer of sauce that wasn't too sweet, healthy layer of cheese, with enough ham and pineapple to fully cover the entire pie - no skimping on toppings here (you get what you pay for!). A medium is 8 slices and great for 1 person to have leftovers, or split between two people with there are other snacks around and no leftovers. Buccaneer might be too expensive to order 5 pizzas to feed a group, but for an individual "splurge" pie or two, I think it's worth it.